Chapter 6: The Original Agreement
Margaret Ellis placed the envelope beneath the examination lamp.
She was in her late sixties, with short silver hair, sharp eyes, and a leather briefcase that looked older than some of the contestants.
Nia had never met her.
But the moment Margaret mentioned her mother, Nia felt an immediate sense of trust.
"Are you really my mother's attorney?"" she asked.
Margaret smiled sadly.
"I have been her attorney for twenty-seven years.""
"Why have I never heard of you?""
"Because your mother asked me to stay away from your childhood. She wanted you to grow up without being pulled into a legal battle you hadn't chosen.""
Nia looked at the envelope.
"What's inside?""
"The original agreement. And something your mother discovered several years after the collection was stolen.""
Victoria stood abruptly.
"I object to this.""
Margaret didn't even look at her.
"You don't have to agree to the existence of a document for it to exist, Victoria.""
Brianna watched the exchange nervously.
"Who is this woman?""
Margaret turned toward her.
"Someone who has spent a considerable amount of time making sure your family cannot erase another woman's work.""
Judge Harris invited Margaret to sit.
"Before we proceed, can you verify the authenticity of these records?""
Margaret opened her briefcase.
"I brought the original signed agreement, the notarized ownership schedule, and correspondence from the foundation.""
She placed each item on the table.
"These documents were preserved in my firm's secure archive. I also have certified copies of the original registration.""
Judge Harris examined the papers.
"This is significant.""
"It is," Margaret replied.
"Especially because the agreement contains a clause that was never disclosed to the foundation's later directors.""
Nia leaned forward.
"What clause?""
Margaret turned the first page toward her.
"Your mother agreed to allow Victoria Cole to manage the commercial presentation of the collection for a limited period.""
"How long?""
"Five years.""
Nia frowned.
"Then what?""
"At the end of those five years, all intellectual property rights were supposed to return to Evelyn Bennett.""
Victoria shook her head.
"That isn't what we agreed.""
Margaret calmly pointed to a paragraph.
"Would you like me to read it aloud?""
Victoria didn't answer.
Margaret continued.
"Upon expiration of the five-year licensing period, all designs, patterns, original sketches, construction specifications, and derivative works shall revert exclusively to Evelyn Rose Bennett unless a separate written extension is executed by both parties.""
Judge Collins examined the signature.
"Was an extension ever signed?""
"No.""
"Then the rights reverted to Evelyn in 2003?""
"Correct.""
Nia looked toward Victoria.
"Which means the collection never belonged to your family permanently.""
Margaret nodded.
"That's right.""
Victoria sat down slowly.
Brianna looked at her mother.
"You told me Grandpa owned the collection.""
"He financed it.""
"That's not the same thing.""
Victoria rubbed her forehead.
"You don't understand the business arrangements.""
Brianna's voice rose.
"I understand that you told me something that wasn't true.""
Victoria looked at her daughter.
"Everything I did was to protect this family.""
Brianna turned away.
Margaret opened the second document.
"But the agreement is only the beginning.""
She removed a photocopy of a letter dated 2003.
It was addressed to Evelyn Bennett.
The letter bore the official seal of Cole Holdings.
Nia read the first few lines.
Her mother's name appeared at the top.
Then she noticed the signature.
It belonged to Victoria.
The letter acknowledged that the five-year licensing period had expired and that the designs would return to Evelyn.
But the final paragraph contained a condition.
In consideration of the commercial success achieved through the collection, the parties agree to negotiate a reasonable buyout of all future rights.
Nia frowned.
"Did my mother agree to sell?""
Margaret shook her head.
"No. She refused.""
"Then why did the letter say that?""
"Because Victoria attempted to persuade her to accept a buyout.""
Victoria suddenly spoke.
"I offered her a substantial amount.""
Margaret turned toward her.
"You offered her five thousand dollars.""
"It was a generous amount at the time.""
"For an internationally licensed collection?""
Victoria's voice tightened.
"She could have taken it.""
Nia stared at her.
"Five thousand dollars?""
Margaret nodded.
"Your mother declined. She wanted her designs returned and her name restored.""
"What happened?""
"Nothing," Margaret said.
"Cole Holdings continued licensing the collection through several subsidiary companies.""
Judge Harris looked shocked.
"Even after the agreement expired?""
"Yes.""
Victoria stood again.
"The designs had become part of the company's portfolio!""
"Without legal authorization," Margaret replied.
Victoria's face reddened.
"Your mother was impossible to work with. She rejected every offer.""
"She rejected offers to sell work that belonged to her.""
Margaret opened another file.
"This is why I came tonight. There is evidence that the unauthorized licensing continued until 2019.""
Nia stared at her.
"Twenty-one years?""
"Twenty-one years.""
Margaret slid a financial statement across the table.
"Your mother never received royalties from those transactions.""
Nia felt her anger rising again.
"Why didn't you stop them?""
"We tried.""
Margaret looked exhausted.
"Your mother filed several legal notices. But the companies involved were structured through different entities, and each time we pursued one, another appeared. The litigation became extremely expensive.""
"Then why didn't you tell me?""
"Your mother believed you deserved the chance to establish yourself independently.""
Nia lowered her eyes.
"She shouldn't have had to fight alone.""
Margaret reached across the table.
"She wasn't alone. She had me. But she wanted you to have a different beginning.""
Judge Harris looked through the financial statements.
"Margaret, what is the current legal status of the designs?""
"All original designs created by Evelyn remain hers. Any unauthorized reproductions or derivatives may also be subject to claims, depending on the evidence.""
Judge Collins nodded.
"And the gown worn tonight?""
Margaret examined the competition submission photographs.
"That gown appears to be a reproduction of Evelyn's original work, incorporating Nia Bennett's more recent adaptations.""
Nia looked confused.
"Adaptations?""
Margaret turned toward her.
"Your mother told me you had redesigned the original silhouette for this competition.""
"Yes.""
"Then the current gown combines your creative work with your mother's original design elements.""
Brianna looked up.
"That's impossible.""
Nia frowned.
"What?""
Brianna stood.
"The dress I submitted was based on a sketch I found in my grandmother's archive.""
Margaret turned toward her.
"Which sketch?""
Brianna pointed at the photograph from the archive.
"The original floral design. My mother said our family had owned the collection for decades.""
Nia stared at her.
"That was my mother's design.""
"I didn't know that.""
"But you saw my submission.""
Brianna looked down.
"I saw your sketches.""
"And you copied them.""
Brianna's eyes filled.
"I thought they were part of the same collection.""
Nia shook her head.
"That doesn't explain why you submitted them under your name.""
Brianna looked toward the judges.
"I made changes.""
Margaret examined the submission photograph.
"Changing the color palette and adding embroidery does not establish authorship of an existing design.""
Brianna turned toward her mother.
"You said the archive was ours.""
Victoria's expression hardened.
"It was our family archive.""
"That doesn't mean the work belonged to us!""
"Enough, Brianna.""
"No! You've been telling me my entire life that I was following in our family's tradition. You told me my grandmother was a designer. You told me this scholarship was part of our legacy.""
Victoria's eyes narrowed.
"Your grandmother did build a business.""
"With Evelyn's work!""
Victoria slapped her palm against the table.
"Do you think I wanted any of this?""
Brianna flinched.
The room fell silent.
Margaret slowly closed the financial statement.
"There is another reason I came tonight.""
She looked at Nia.
"Your mother asked me to give you something if this matter ever became public.""
Margaret opened a small inner compartment of her briefcase.
Inside was a photograph and a handwritten note.
The photograph showed Evelyn standing beside a younger Victoria.
They were holding a document between them.
On the back, someone had written:
October 14, 1998. Evelyn refuses to surrender her name.
Nia unfolded the note.
It contained only a few lines.
*My darling girl, if you're reading this, it means the truth has finally reached you. I need you to understand something. I never wanted the Cole family to suffer.
I only wanted my work returned. Do not let anger turn you into someone you don't recognize. Fight for what is right, but never forget who you are.*
Nia pressed the note against her chest.
For a moment, the noise of the auditorium disappeared.
She could almost hear her mother's voice.
Margaret waited until Nia looked up.
"There's one final issue.""
Judge Harris leaned forward.
"What is it?""
Margaret removed a final sheet from the envelope.
It was a copy of the original scholarship trust deed.
At the bottom, beneath the signatures of the founding trustees, was a paragraph that had been marked in red ink.
Judge Harris read it.
Then he looked at Daniel.
"Is this accurate?""
Daniel's expression changed.
"Yes.""
Nia glanced between them.
"What does it say?""
Margaret answered.
"The scholarship foundation was required to reserve one permanent seat on its board for the original designer whose work funded its establishment.""
Judge Collins frowned.
"Was that seat ever filled?""
Daniel shook his head.
"No. It was quietly removed from the foundation's published structure.""
Margaret turned the document around.
"And the original designer was named as Evelyn Rose Bennett.""
Nia stared at the page.
Her mother hadn't simply been the creator of the collection.
She had been entitled to a permanent position in the very institution that had built its reputation on her work.
Judge Harris slowly rose.
"If this trust deed is valid, the foundation has a serious governance problem.""
Victoria looked toward the exit.
Brianna noticed.
"Mom, where are you going?""
Victoria grabbed her purse.
"This meeting is over.""
Margaret stood.
"Not quite.""
She placed one final photograph on the table.
It showed a younger Victoria signing a document in front of a notary.
Beside her sat Evelyn.
And behind them stood a third person.
A man Nia had never seen before.
Daniel Whitmore stared at the photograph.
His face changed instantly.
"Where did you get that?""
Margaret looked at him.
"From Evelyn's personal archive.""
Daniel took a step closer.
"That man was supposed to be dead.""
Nia examined the photograph.
"Who is he?""
Daniel swallowed.
Then he said a name that made Victoria drop her purse.
"Richard Cole.""
Brianna looked confused.
"That's my grandfather.""
Daniel shook his head.
"No. That's your grandfather's younger brother.""
Margaret nodded.
"And according to Evelyn's records, he was the person who secretly financed the theft of the collection.""
Nia looked at the photograph again.
"Why would he do that?""
Margaret's expression turned grave.
"Because Richard Cole wasn't simply interested in stealing your mother's designs.""
She paused.
"He wanted to make sure Evelyn Bennett would never receive the scholarship she had originally won.""
May you like
And the reason, Margaret explained, was hidden in a second agreement that had never been shown to the foundation.
An agreement that could expose a betrayal far bigger than anyone in the auditorium had imagined.
