Blue

Chapter 2: The Voicemail at Midnight

Daniel had spent seven years believing the worst thing that could happen to a man was losing his wife.

He was about to discover that grief had been the easy part.

The metallic click came again.

Every instinct in his body screamed at him to grab Lily and run, but the chapel was crowded. Guests were standing in the aisles. Several had already raised their phones, recording the scene as though it were an argument at a reality-TV wedding.

“Everyone stay where you are!”” Daniel shouted.

The words startled even him.

His daughter pressed herself against his leg.

“Daddy, I'm scared.””

He crouched and wrapped his arms around her.

“I know, sweetheart. I'm right here.””

Brielle stood near the altar, trembling in her wedding dress.

“Daniel, what is happening?””

He didn't answer.

Instead, he scanned the room.

The chapel had three exits: the main doors behind them, a side door near the choir, and a narrow passage leading to the vestry. The passage was partly concealed by heavy velvet curtains.

A man in a charcoal suit stood beside those curtains.

Daniel recognized him.

Richard Vale, Brielle's uncle and the man who had managed her family's affairs for decades.

Richard was sixty-two, silver-haired, and almost offensively composed. He had been the one to welcome Daniel into the Whitmore family, the one who had toasted their engagement, and the one who had insisted on paying for the wedding.

Now Richard's right hand rested inside his jacket.

Daniel's eyes locked onto it.

“Richard,” he said.

“Take your hand out of your pocket.””

Richard smiled without warmth.

“Daniel, I think emotions are running a little high.””

“Your hand. Now.””

“Let's not make a scene.””

“You brought a weapon into a chapel. The scene is already here.””

A woman in the front row gasped.

Richard's smile disappeared.

“Brielle,” he said, never taking his eyes off Daniel, “come here.””

She didn't move.

For the first time, Daniel saw her hesitate when Richard gave an order.

“Brielle,” Richard repeated.

“Now.””

Her eyes flicked toward Lily.

Then toward Daniel's closed fist, where the brass key was hidden.

And she whispered, “Uncle Richard, please.””

That single sentence told Daniel more than all her denials had.

He moved Lily behind him.

“Did you know my wife was alive?””

Richard sighed as though Daniel had asked an inconvenient question during a business meeting.

“Your wife is dead.””

“Then why are you carrying a gun?””

“Security.””

“At my wedding?””

“Given the circumstances, I'd say it was wise.””

Daniel's jaw tightened.

“What circumstances?””

Richard glanced at the guests.

“Perhaps we should discuss this privately.””

“No.””

“Daniel, think about Lily. Do you really want her watching this?””

Daniel felt his daughter clutch the back of his jacket.

He did think about Lily.

He thought about her first day of school, when she had cried because every other child had drawn a picture of their mother for a family project. He thought about the little wooden box in her bedroom containing Elisa's wedding ring, which he had given her when she turned five.

He thought about every time she had asked whether her mother could see her from heaven.

And he thought about how Brielle had always answered before he could.

Your mommy would be so proud of you.

Your mommy would want you to be happy.

Your mommy would want you to stop asking questions.

Daniel had mistaken those words for kindness.

Now they sounded like instructions.

“Lily,” he whispered, “do you remember where you found Mommy?””

She nodded against his back.

“In the old house.””

His blood ran cold.

“What old house?””

“The house with the blue door.””

Daniel knew exactly which house she meant.

Elisa's childhood home stood outside town, a weather-beaten property on the edge of the Blue Ridge Mountains. Her parents had sold most of their belongings after her death, but the house itself had remained in a family trust.

Daniel hadn't visited in years.

“Who took you there?”” he asked.

“A lady.””

“What lady?””

Lily hesitated.

“She said her name was Nora. She knew Mommy.””

Daniel had never heard of a Nora connected to Elisa.

“What happened?””

“She came to the house last night. She said Mommy couldn't come because bad people were watching her. She gave me the picture and the letter.””

Daniel felt his stomach tighten.

“Last night? How did you get here?””

“I took the bus.””

He stared at her.

“You took a bus from the mountains?””

Lily nodded miserably.

“Nora said to ask the driver for the chapel. She gave me money. But the bus stopped at the station, and I got lost. A man in a black car said he knew you.””

Daniel's blood turned to ice.

“What man?””

“He had a scar here.”” Lily touched the left side of her chin.

“He said he would take me to Daddy. But I remembered what Mommy told me.””

“What did she tell you?””

“Never get in a car with someone who knows your name but doesn't know your favorite song.””

For one heartbreaking second, Daniel almost laughed.

It was exactly the kind of rule Elisa would have invented.

“What did you do?””

“I ran.””

Her scraped knees suddenly made sense.

“I ran through the woods behind the station. Then I saw the church sign. I thought if I got here before the wedding ended, you would still be here.””

Daniel closed his eyes.

His seven-year-old daughter had crossed half a county alone because a stranger had told her that her mother was alive.

He opened his eyes and looked at Richard.

“Who was the man with the scar?””

Richard's expression barely changed.

“Children imagine things.””

Daniel rose.

“That's what Brielle said.””

“And she may be right.””

“Is that why you have a gun?””

Richard's gaze dropped to Daniel's fist.

“The key, Daniel.””

“What?””

“Give me the key.””

“No.””

“You don't know what it opens.””

“Then tell me.””

Richard took a slow step forward.

“That key belongs to the past. It has nothing to do with your future.””

Daniel tightened his grip.

“Funny. My wife seems to think otherwise.””

Richard's face hardened.

“Your wife is not coming back.””

From beside the altar, Brielle suddenly spoke.

“Stop it, Uncle Richard!””

Everyone turned toward her.

She was crying now, but her voice was firm.

“Please, stop.””

Richard stared at her with quiet fury.

“You have no idea what you're doing.””

“Neither do you.””

He took another step.

“Brielle, think carefully about what you say next.””

She flinched.

Daniel saw it.

He saw the way her shoulders curled inward, the way her fingers twisted the fabric of her dress, the way she looked at Richard as if she had spent years anticipating his anger.

Something complicated and ugly was unfolding in front of him.

Perhaps Brielle was guilty.

Perhaps she was frightened.

Perhaps she was both.

But he could not afford to guess.

Daniel reached into his pocket and pulled out his phone.

He dialed 911.

Richard moved immediately.

“Don't.””

Daniel held up his free hand.

“Stay where you are.””

“You don't understand the danger you're inviting.””

“Then the police can explain it to me.””

Richard's jaw clenched.

For one moment, Daniel thought he would draw the gun.

Instead, Richard stepped behind the curtain.

A sharp bang echoed through the chapel.

Someone screamed.

Daniel ducked over Lily, shielding her head with his body.

When he looked up, the curtain was swinging.

Richard had disappeared.

A side door slammed in the distance.

“Lock the doors!”” someone shouted.

The chapel erupted into chaos.

Guests surged toward the exits. The organist abandoned his bench. Brielle stumbled down the altar steps, gathering her dress in both hands.

“Daniel!””

He ignored her and pulled Lily toward the main doors.

“Daddy, where are we going?””

“Somewhere safe.””

“Are we going to find Mommy?””

He looked at her small face.

He wanted to promise her everything.

Instead, he said, “I'm going to find out what happened.””

Outside, sirens wailed in the distance.

Daniel led Lily to his black SUV, parked near the chapel entrance. He unlocked the rear door and helped her climb inside.

“Stay down, sweetheart.””

She grabbed his wrist.

“Don't leave me.””

“I won't.””

He climbed into the driver's seat, locked the doors, and immediately checked the mirrors.

No Richard.

No black car.

No one approaching.

Only the chapel windows glowing behind him and a crowd gathering on the front steps.

Daniel took out his phone.

The voicemail was still waiting.

Seventeen seconds.

He pressed play and held the phone against his ear.

At first, he heard only static.

Then Elisa's voice.

“Daniel, if you're hearing this, the key has reached you. Don't take it to the police. Don't take it to the house. There's a second key, and Brielle has it.””

A pause.

Then a faint sound, like a door opening.

Elisa continued, her voice breaking.

“I'm sorry about what happened to your father. I know you were told he died in an accident, but he didn't. Richard knows what really happened, and Brielle—”

The recording crackled.

A man's voice interrupted her.

“Who are you talking to?””

Elisa gasped.

The recording ended.

Daniel lowered the phone.

His father, Thomas Hayes, had died in a car accident when Daniel was twenty-four. His car had gone through a guardrail on a rainy night. The police had called it a tragic loss of control.

Daniel had buried his father long before he buried Elisa.

He had never suspected foul play.

He replayed the message.

There's a second key, and Brielle has it.

Daniel turned toward the chapel.

Brielle stood beneath the stone archway, her wedding veil hanging loose around her shoulders. She was speaking to a uniformed officer, but her eyes were fixed on Daniel's SUV.

When she saw him looking, she raised one hand.

Not waving.

Warning him.

Then she mouthed two words.

Don't leave.

Daniel stared at her.

His phone buzzed.

A new message appeared from the unknown number.

*SHE HAS THE SECOND KEY. IF YOU WANT YOUR WIFE ALIVE, ASK BRIELLE WHAT HAPPENED THE NIGHT YOUR FATHER DIED.*

Lily leaned forward from the back seat.

“Daddy?””

He turned.

“Yeah, sweetheart?””

“Mommy told Nora something else.””

Daniel felt his pulse quicken.

“What?””

Lily looked at the chapel, then back at him.

“She said if you ever found out what happened to Grandpa Thomas, you would understand why she had to disappear.””

Daniel went still.

Outside, Brielle suddenly broke away from the police officer and ran toward his car.

She struck the passenger window with the palm of her hand.

“Daniel! Open the door!””

He kept the locks engaged.

She pressed her face to the glass.

“Please,” she whispered.

“He's coming back.””

“Who?””

Brielle looked over her shoulder.

A black sedan had just turned into the chapel parking lot.

Daniel recognized the vehicle from Lily's description.

The man with the scar stepped out.

He wasn't carrying an umbrella despite the rain.

May you like

He was carrying a gun.

And he was walking straight toward Lily's door.

Related Stories

Other posts